THE ENGLISH-AS-A-SECOND-LANGUAGE STUDENT

Professors Nancy S. Lay and Gladys Carro
What kinds of learning needs do ESL students bring to the classroom?
Among the second-language learners that come into our classrooms, there
are different kinds of ESL students. The students who are born in the U.S.
or came to this country at an early age and are a product of our public
schools often are fluent orally, but have difficulties in writing and reading.
They may speak with some interferences from their first language or dialect.
Another group is the foreign-educated adults with some knowledge of English.
They are graduates of secondary schools in their native country and frequently
have good reading and writing abilities. The third group are international
students with limited knowledge of English. Many of these students are literate
in their own language. There may, however, be a small number of non-native
speakers who are not literate in their own language.
Needs
1. Linguistic - The typical ESL class students have been in this country
five years or less. However, the ESL Department feels there are some second-language
students that have lived here for more than five or six years, but who still
have second language needs. We believe that these students could also benefit
from ESL classes, since our teachers are trained to work with them. However,
these students, especially if they have been here awhile and are fluent
in oral skills, feel that they are "better off" than students
who are shy and who do not speak that much in the classroom. This is more
of a psychological problem for them.
One of the biggest problems facing ESL students is note-taking from lectures
and textbooks because of their inability to synthesize and paraphrase information
quickly. It takes time for them to decode and encode a language that is
not their own. On the other hand, some of them might be good in the written
language, but fall short in the spoken language. Allow them some time before
moving on.
Another problem is reading comprehension and vocabulary. Many of the textbooks
are written on a reading level far higher than that attained by many ESL
students. Thus, reading becomes slow and checking the dictionary for every
word they do not know takes time and
interrupts the comprehensibility of the texts. Many of them do not have
the habit of reading a lot in English. They do not make connections from
what they learn in one class with what they learn in another and they do
not make connections from what they learned in the past with the present.
For some students, poor self-image and low self-esteem contribute to the
whole learning experience.
2. Cultural - ESL students tend to remain silent unless called upon. Many
of them will not respond to a question unless they are encouraged and given
time to answer. They are afraid to lose face in front of their peers. Until
they are sure of the answers, many times they do not volunteer. Many expressions
in the English language require an American cultural background to understand,
for example, "Achilles' heel." ESL students may not know the connection
between the expression and the original use of it.
What are some of the strategies that teachers can employ to assist ESL students?
There is no one way to help ESL students. However, we know that the more
we know about our students and where they come from, the better we can help
them.
Teaching
- Avoid long lectures. If you have to lecture, cut it into smaller
units and review each section before moving on to the next section. The
point here is: Did my students comprehend what I was saying?
- Use natural conventional language. Do not take anything for granted.
- Focus on the students' strengths, rather than weaknesses, at first.
Work from the familiar to the unfamiliar. Let students bring in their experiences
and connect those experiences to what is being taught.
- Have a glossary of new words or key words in the chapter and go over
the list with them before discussing the chapter.
- Listen more to your students.
- Try to provide as many examples as possible; rephrase your statements
in simple language. Do not expect ESL students to understand your question
the first time.
- When dealing with students' written work, try to make constructive
remarks so that the student can use your remarks to learn something about
the language.
- Allow ESL students to respond orally before they do a written assignment.
This way you are sure that they understood the assignment. Many times ESL
students think they understand the assignment when in fact they do not and,
worst of all, they do not ask questions. It is a good teaching strategy
to ask them to rephrase the assignment to each other to make sure everything
is clear.
- Use collaborative learning or small group work. Explain to your students
why you are using a certain methodology. Many ESL students come from traditional
educational systems and, for them, the only way to learn is from the instructor,
who "knows all." For collaborative learning and group work to
be successful, one has to prepare ahead of time the tasks and goals to be
achieved. These tasks have to be clearly instructed; if not, then the work
group becomes a waste of time.
- Some students are shy about participating in class. Call on them.
Help them prepare for the next time. This way they will fell more confident.
When ESL students do not speak up, many instructors think that they do not
have any ideas. This is not true!
- Write assignments on the board. Do not give assignments orally. Try
to be patient and supportive and express interest in their experiences,
language, and culture; do not be judgmental. Be aware of body language.
Advisement
- For many ESL students, seeking advisement is a sign of losing face.
One has to explain to them what advisement entails, and that it is not a
negative thing. Seek out students who need help and talk to them privately.
Classroom Routines and Evaluation
Since English as a Second Language students (ESLers) come from such a wide
variety of backgrounds, the quality, quantity and rigor of their prior schooling
differs greatly. Teachers may find an older student - a professional architect
from the Soviet Union or Israel - sitting next to a seventeen year-old high
school graduate from a developing nation. Assumptions about teaching techniques
and learning modes must not be made. The latest poll among ESLers at City
suggested that the student body represents as many as 120 countries and
speaks 85 languages. We have Hispanics from Spain, Colombia, Mexico, Ecuador,
and the Dominican Republic. The experiences of students from these countries
are as different as the countries they come from. We have French-speaking
students from Paris, and others from Port-au-Prince. We may have five students
from China and each speaks a different language. In terms of the students'
English language comprehension, little should be taken for granted. Most
students learned English very differently from the manner American teachers
would teach it, and most learned a lot about it, but still speak and understand
very little English.
Classroom routines - Classroom routines and due dates for assignments
must not change many times throughout the term. ESLers take longer than
native speakers to get required readings done. Generally speaking, most
ESLers like to work alone. Individual assignments are good, but do not help
language development as much as group work. When reviewing a reading assignment,
teachers may want to put students in groups of four. Limit the discussion
to no more than two or three topics and assign each group member a task.
The task may be reporting back to the class, keeping the discussion focused,
or taking notes. This routine helps students listen to how others understood
the text and each student is able to confirm for themselves what they read.
If a teacher gives a lecture and has students take notes, it is a good idea
for a few students to read their notes to each other. What one student didn't
understand, perhaps another understood. Talking about what they learned
and how they arrived at the conclusion helps them clarify their thoughts.
Collaborative assignments help ESLers motivate themselves. Students enjoy
"showing off" what they know to others; it encourages oral presentation
and public speaking and helps them evaluate themselves compared to other
students.
Testing and evaluation - Many ESLers come from school systems that
emphasized memory-based education. That is, after each year of school, all
students took a national exam which determined entry into the next grade.
A student had to pass all sections or all subjects on the exam or the entire
school year had to be repeated. Generally speaking, ESLers like to memorize
and be tested on facts. Therefore, when American teachers require comprehension
and application of the material, students may experience difficulty unless
they are told and shown exactly what is expected. For instance, a World
Civilization professor asked the class to trace the roots of a civilization.
Some students translated "trace" as something that is done in
art class. Another student asked which section of the text was dedicated
specifically to answering the question. Another example of this type of
miscommunication was on an essay assignment; the question read "discuss
the daily living among the river valleys; include Mesopotamia and other
civilizations and areas we have studied this term." Most of the students
only cited facts about Mesopotamia; they completely ignored the other areas
they had studied.
As the above examples illustrate, most ESLers do not understand many text
and test questions. Be specific as to what is required for the assignment.
Words like 'classify', 'embellish', 'personalize', 'illustrate', 'speculate',
'criticize', 'validate', and 'qualify' will cause some difficulty for ESLers
unless the teacher is very clear about what is to be done, and how.
ESLers may be confused when teachers routinely ask the students what "they"
think. Some of these foreign students feel that teachers get paid to know
their subject and if the teacher constantly asks "Why," then the
teacher must be weak. Students pay tuition to be "given knowledge",
or shown how to get it, not to be asked what they came to learn about. Memory-based
education gives students the facts. There is little or no problem-solving
or critical thinking required in these classes.
When term papers are assigned, it is always a good idea to divide the assignment
into stages. The note cards and research should be checked before the first
draft is submitted. Review footnoting formats completely. Due to limited
vocabulary in English, many students find it difficult to paraphrase and
are accused of plagiarism. Some students think that simply changing a few
words is sufficient. When grading a term paper or other written assignment,
it is a good idea to give a fraction for a grade. The numerator for worth
of the paper's content, and the denominator for correct use of language
and grammar. This format shows the student where most of their writing weakness
lies.
If essays are assigned, remember that ESLers do not write quickly. Timed
exams are the most difficult since these students need to "translate"
their thoughts, then compose and edit their piece. The process is far more
arduous than what native speakers are accustomed to.
Multiple choice tests should not be given because this type of exam does
not encourage language development; they simply assess the student's basic
ability to retrieve material. Students like this type of testing, but it
is not beneficial to the language learning process.
Professor Nancy S. Lay
English as a Second Language
NAC Building, Room R5/218
(212) 650-6284
E-mail: nalcc@cunyvm.cuny.edu
Professor Gladys Carro
English as a Second Language
NAC Building, Room R5/218
(212) 650-6286